J. V. Stalin

ON THE OPPOSITION

(1921-27)


Table of Contents




C O N T E N T S
(Abbreviated)



OUR DISAGREEMENTS  (more)
 

1
 

THE PARTY'S TASKSReport Delivered at an Enlarged Meeting of
  the Krasnaya Presnya District Committee of the R.C.P.(B.)
, with
  Group Organisers
, Members of the Debating Society and of the
  Bureau of the Party Units
, December 2, 1923  (more)
 


 
 
12
 

THE DISCUSSION, RAFAIL, THE ARTICLES BY PREOBRAZHENSKY AND
  SAPRONOV, AND TROTSKY'S LETTER (more)
 


28
 

A NECESSARY COMMENT (Concerning Rafail)
 

45
 

THE THIRTEENTH CONFERENCE OF THE R.C.P.(B.),  January 16-18,
  1924  (more)
 


49
 

THIRTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE R.C.P.(B.),  May 23-31, 1924  (more)
 

88
 
 

THE RESULTS OF THE THIRTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE R.C.P.(B.).,
  Excerpts from the Report Delivered at the C.C., R.C.P.(B.)
  Courses for Secretaries of Vyezd Party Committees
, June 17,
  1924
 


 
 
102
 

TROTSKYISM OR LENINISMSpeech Delivered at the Plenum of
  the Communist Group in the A.U.C.C.T.U.
, November 19, 1924
 (more)
 


105
 
 

THE OCTOBER REVOLUTION AND THE TACTICS OF THE RUSSIAN
  COMMUNISTSPreface to the Book "On the Road to October"
              [Transcriber's Note: See Problems of Leninism. -- DJR]
 


139
 
 

SPEECH DELIVERED AT A PLENUM OF THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE AND
  THE CENTRAL CONTROL COMMISSION OF THE R.C.P.(B.),
  January 17, 1925
 


 
183
 

THE RESULTS OF THE WORK OF THE FOURTEENTH CONFERENCE OF
  THE R.C.P.(B.). Report Delivered at a Meeting of the Activists
  of the Moscow Organization of the R.C.P.(B.)
, May 9, 1925  (more)
 


 
188
 

THE FOURTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE C.P.S.U.(B.), December 18-31,
  1925  (more)
 


230
 

CONCERNING QUESTIONS OF LENINISM
              [Transcriber's Note: See Problems of Leninism. -- DJR]
 

268
 
 

THE ANGLO-RUSSIAN UNITY COMMITTEESpeech Delivered at a
  Joint Plenum of the Central Committee and the Central Control
  Commission of the C.P.S.U.(B.)
, July 15, 1926
 


 
347
 

THE OPPOSITION BLOC IN THE C.P.S.U.(B.Theses for the Fifteenth
  All-Union Conference of the C.P.S.U.(B.)
, adopted by the Confer-
  ence and Endorsed by the C.C.
, C.P.S.U.(B.), July 15, 1926  (more)
 


 
363
 

THE SOCIAL-DEMOCRATIC DEVIATION IN OUR PARTYReport
  Delivered at the Fiftheenth All-Union Conference of the
  C.P.S.U.(B.)
, November 1, 1926  (more)
 


 
382
 

REPLY TO THE DISCUSSION ON THE REPORT ON "THE SOCIAL-DEMO-
  CRATIC DEVIATION IN OUR PARTY," November 3, 1926  (more)
 


442
 

THE PROSPECTS OF THE REVOLUTION IN CHINASpeech Delivered
  in the Chinese Commission of the E.C.C.I.
, November 30, 1926  (more)
 


499
 
 

THE SEVENTH ENLARGED PLENUM OF THE E.C.C.I.November 22 -
  December 16
, 1926  (more)
 


517
 

QUESTIONS OF THE CHINESE REVOLUTIONTheses for Propagand-
  ists
, Approved by the C.C., C.P.S.U.(B.)  (more)
 


657
 

TALK WITH STUDENTS OF THE SUN YAT-SEN UNIVERSITYMay 13,
  1927
 


667
 

THE REVOLUTION IN CHINA AND THE TASKS OF THE COMINTERN.
  Speech Delivered at the Tenth Sitting, Eighth Plenum of the
  E.C.C.I.
, May 241927  (more)
 


 
696
 

NOTES ON CONTEMPORARY THEMES  (more)
 

726
 

JOINT PLENUM OF THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE AND THE CENTRAL
  CONTROL COMMISSION OF THE C.P.S.U.(B.), July 29-August 9,
  1927  (more)
 


 
765
 

THE POLITICAL COMPLEXION OF THE RUSSIAN OPPOSITION.
  Excerpts from a Speech Delivered at a Joint Meeting of the
  Presidium of the Executive Committee of the Comintern and
  the International Control Commission
, September 27, 1927
 


 
 
850
 

THE TROTSKYIST OPPOSITION BEFORE AND NOWSpeech Delivered
  at a Meeting of the Joint Plenum of the Central Committee and
  the Central Control Commission of the C.P.S.U.(B.)
, October 23,
  1927  (more)
 


 
 
864
 



From Marx
to Mao

Reading
Guide

Stalin
Collection

Complete Table
of Contents Below



J. V. Stalin

ON THE OPPOSITION

(1921-27)

Table of Contents
(Complete)



OUR DISAGREEMENTS

1

I.
II.
 

Two Methods of Approach to the Mass of the Workers
Conscious Democracy and Forced "Democracy"
 

2
4
 

THE PARTY'S TASKSReport Delivered at an Enlarged Meeting of
  the Krasnaya Presnya District Committee of the R.C.P.(B.)
, with
  Group Organisers
, Members of the Debating Society and of the
  Bureau of the Party Units
, December 2, 1923


 
 
12

  Discussion -- a Sign of the Party's Strength
  Causes of the Discussion
  Defects in Internal Party Life
  The Causes of the Defects
  How Should the Defects in Internal Party Life Be Removed?
 

13
14
15
17
20
 

THE DISCUSSION, RAFAIL, THE ARTICLES BY PREOBRAZHENSKY AND
  SAPRONOV, AND TROTSKY'S LETTER


28

  The Discussion
  Rafail
  Preobrazhensky's Article
  Sapronov's Article
  Trotsky's Letter
 

28
31
35
37
40
 

A NECESSARY COMMENT (Concerning Rafail)
 

45
 

THE THIRTEENTH CONFERENCE OF THE R.C.P.(B.),  January 16-18,
  1924


49

I.
II.
 

Report on Immediate Tasks in Party Affairs, January 17
Reply to the Discussion, January 18
 

49
69
 

THIRTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE R.C.P.(B.),  May 23-31, 1924



[Transcriber's Note: This document, as it appears in On the Opposition, repro-
duces only the second part of the complete text (roughly a third of the entire document). The following listing of its contents is for the complete document.
Since I have reproduced the entire text directly from Stalin's Works, all page references have omitted here. -- DJR]



Organisational Report of the Central Committee, May 24



1.
2.
3.
4.
 
5.
6.
 
7.
8.

The Mass Organisations That Link the Party With the Class
The State Apparatus
The Composition of the Party. The Lenin Enrolment
The Composition of the Leading Party Bodies. Cadres and the Younger
 Party Element
The Work of the Party in the Sphere of Agitation and Propaganda
The Work of the Party in the Registration, Allocation and Promotion
 of Forces
Inner-Party Life
Conclusions



[Transcriber's Note: The following is that part of the text reproduced in On the Opposition -- DJR]


Reply to the Discussion, May 27
 


THE RESULTS OF THE THIRTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE R.C.P.(B.).,
  Excerpts from the Report Delivered at the C.C., R.C.P.(B.)
  Courses for Secretaries of Vyezd Party Committees
, June 17,
  1924


 
 
102


[Transcriber's Note: The "excerpts" alluded to here amount to fewer than three pages out a total of twenty-eight comprising the entire document. The following listing of contents is for the complete document, which I have reproduced in its entirety from Stalin's Works, omitting the page references. -- DJR]


Foreign Affairs
Questions of the Bond Between Town and Country
Questions of the Education and Re-education of the Working
  Masses
The Party
The Tasks of Party Workers in the Uyezds
 


TROTSKYISM OR LENINISMSpeech Delivered at the Plenum of
  the Communist Group in the A.U.C.C.T.U.
, November 19, 1924


105

I.
II.
III.
 

The Facts About the October Uprising
The Party and the Preparation for October
Trotskyism or Leninism?
 

105
112
128
 

THE OCTOBER REVOLUTION AND THE TACTICS OF THE RUSSIAN
  COMMUNISTSPreface to the Book "On the Road to October"
              [Transcriber's Note: See Problems of Leninism. -- DJR]
 


139
 
 

SPEECH DELIVERED AT A PLENUM OF THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE AND
  THE CENTRAL CONTROL COMMISSION OF THE R.C.P.(B.),
  January 17, 1925
 


 
183
 

THE RESULTS OF THE WORK OF THE FOURTEENTH CONFERENCE OF
  THE R.C.P.(B.). Report Delivered at a Meeting of the Activists
  of the Moscow Organization of the R.C.P.(B.)
, May 9, 1925


 
188

I.
II.
 
III.
 
IV.
V.
VI.
 

The International Situation
The Immediate Tasks of the Communist Parties in the Capitalist Countries
The Immediate Tasks of the Communist Elements in the Colonial and Dependent Countries
The Fate of Socialism in the Soviet Union
The Party's Policy in the Countryside
The Metal Industry
 

189
 
199
 
204
206
218
225
 

THE FOURTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE C.P.S.U.(B.), December 18-31,
  1925


230


[Transcriber's Note: This document, as it appears in On the Opposition, repro-
duces only the second part of the complete text (roughly a third of the entire document). The following listing of its contents is for the complete document.
Since I have reproduced the entire text directly from Stalin's Works, all page references have omitted here. -- DJR]


 Political Report of the Central Committee, December 18


I.

The International Situation



1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

The Stabilisation of Capitalism
Imperialism, the Colonies and Semi-Colonies
Victors and Vanquished
The Contradictions between the Victor Countries
The Capitalist World and the Soviet Union
The External Position of the U.S.S.R.
The Party's Tasks


II.

The Internal Situation in the Soviet Union



1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

The National Economy as a Whole
Industry and Agriculture
Questions Concerning Trade
Classes, Their Activity, Their Correlation
Lenin's Three Slogans on the Peasant Question
Two Dangers and Two Deviations in Regard to the Peasant Question
The Party's Tasks


III.

The Party



[Transcriber's Note: The following is a listing for that part of the text reproduced in On the Opposition -- DJR]

 Reply to the Discussion on the Political Report of the Central
  Committee, December 23



1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
 

Sokolnikov and the Dawesation of Our Country
Kamenev and Our Concessions
Whose Miscalculations?
How Sokolnikov Protects the Poor Peasants
Ideological Struggle or Slander?
Concerning NEP
Concerning State Capitalism
Zinoviev and the Peasantry
Concerning the History of the Disagreements
The Opposition's Platform
Their "Desire for Peace"
The Party Will Acheive Unity
 


CONCERNING QUESTIONS OF LENINISM
              [Transcriber's Note: See Problems of Leninism. -- DJR]
 

268
 
 

THE ANGLO-RUSSIAN UNITY COMMITTEESpeech Delivered at a
  Joint Plenum of the Central Committee and the Central Control
  Commission of the C.P.S.U.(B.)
, July 15, 1926
 


 
347
 

THE OPPOSITION BLOC IN THE C.P.S.U.(B.Theses for the Fifteenth
  All-Union Conference of the C.P.S.U.(B.)
, adopted by the Confer-
  ence and Endorsed by the C.C.
, C.P.S.U.(B.), July 15, 1926


 
363

I.
 
 
II.
III.
 
IV.
 

The Passing Over of the "New Opposition" to Trotskyism on
the Basic Question of the Character and Prospects of Our
Revolution
The Practical Platform of the Opposition Bloc
The "Revolutionary" Words and Opportunist Deeds of the
Opposition Bloc
Conclusions
 


 
365
370
 
376
380
 

THE SOCIAL-DEMOCRATIC DEVIATION IN OUR PARTYReport
  Delivered at the Fiftheenth All-Union Conference of the
  C.P.S.U.(B.)
, November 1, 1926


 
382

I.

The Stages of Development of the Opposition Bloc

382


1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

The First Stage
The Second Stage
The Third Stage
The Fourth Stage
Lenin and the Question of Bloc in the Party
The Process of Decomposition of the Opposition Bloc
What is the Opposition Bloc Counting on?

383
384
386
387
388
390
392

II.

The Principal Error of the Opposition Bloc

394


1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
 
7.

Preliminary Remarks
Leninism or Trotskyism?
The Resolution of the Fourteenth Conference of the R.C.P.(B.)
The Passing Over of the "New Opposition" to Trotskyism
Trotsky's Evasion
The Decisive Importance of the Question of the Prospects of Our
Constructive Work
The Political Prospects of the Opposition Bloc

395
399
412
415
420
 
424
427

  III.
 

The Political and Organisational Errors of the Opposition
  Bloc


431

IV.
 

Some Conclusions
 

437
 

REPLY TO THE DISCUSSION ON THE REPORT ON "THE SOCIAL-DEMO-
  CRATIC DEVIATION IN OUR PARTY," November 3, 1926


442

I.

Some General Questions

442


1.
2.
3.

Marxism Is Not a Dogma, but a Guide to Action
Some Remarks of Lenin on the Dictatorship of the Proletariat
The Unevenness of Development of the Capitalist Countries

442
451
456

II.

Kamenev Clears the Way for Trotsky

460

 III.
 

An Incredible Muddle, or Zinoviev on Revolutionary Spirit
  and Internationalism


468

IV.

Trotsky Falsifies Leninism

476


1.
2.
3.

Trotsky's Conjuring Tricks, or the Question of "Permanent Revolution"
Juggling with Quotations, or Trotsky Falsifies Leninism
"Trifles" and Curiosities

476
484
490

V.
 

The Practical Platform of the Opposition. The Demands of
  the Party


493

VI.
 

Conclusion
 

496
 

THE PROSPECTS OF THE REVOLUTION IN CHINASpeech Delivered
  in the Chinese Commission of the E.C.C.I.
, November 30, 1926


499

I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
 
VII.
VIII.
 

Character of the Revolution in China
Imperialism and Imperialist Intervention in China
The Revolutionary Army in China
Character of the Future Government in China
The Peasant Question in China
The Proletariat and the Hegemony of the Proletariat in
China
The Question of the Youth in China
Some Conclusions
 

500
501
504
506
509
 
513
514
515
 

THE SEVENTH ENLARGED PLENUM OF THE E.C.C.I.November 22 -
  December 16
, 1926


517

 Once More on the Social-Democratic Deviation in Our Party.
  Report Delivered on December 7


517

I.

Preliminary Remarks

517


1.
2.

Contradictions of Inner-Party Development
Sources of Contradictions Within the Party

517
523

II.
III.

Specific Features of the Opposition in the C.P.S.U.(B.)
The Disagreements in the C.P.S.U.(B.)

526
533


1.
2.
3.
 
4.
5.
 
6.
7.
8.
9.

Questions of Socialist Construction
Factors of the "Respite"
The Unity and Inseparability of the National and International Tasks of
the Revolution
Concerning the History of the Question of Building Socialism
The Special Importance of the Question of Building Socialism in the U.S.S.R.
at the Present Moment
The Perspectives of the Revolution
How the Question Really Stands
The Chances of Victory
Disagreements Over Political Practice

534
538
 
540
542
 
548
551
553
555
557

IV.
V.
VI.
VII.
 

The Opposition at Work
Why the Enemies of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat Praise the Opposition
Defeat of the Opposition
The Practical Meaning and Importance of the Fifteenth Conference of the C.P.S.U.(B.)

560
564
568
 
571

 Reply to the Discussion, December 13

573

I.

Preliminary Remarks

573


1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

We Need Facts, Not Inventions and Tittle-Tattle
Why the Enemies of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat Praise the Opposition
There Are Errors and Errors
The Dictatorship of the Proletariat According Zinoviev
Trotsky's Oracular Sayings
Zinoviev in the Role of a Schoolboy Quoting Marx, Engels, Lenin
Revisionism According to Zinoviev

573
579
585
589
593
595
605

II.

The Question of the Victory of Socialism in Individual Capitalist Countries

609


1.
 
2.

The Prerequisites for Proletarian Revolutions in Individual Countries in the
Period of Imperialism
How Zinoviev "Elaborates" Lenin


609
619

III.

The Question of Building Socialism in the U.S.S.R.

624


1.
 
2.
 
3.
4.

The "Manoeuvres" of the Opposition and the "National-Reformism" of Lenin's
Party
We Are Building and Can Completely Build the Economic Basis of Socialism in
the U.S.S.R.
We Are Building Socialism in Alliance with the World Proletariat
The Question of Degeneration


624
 
634
645
648

IV.
V.
 

The Opposition and the Question of Party Unity
Conclusion
 


650
654
 

QUESTIONS OF THE CHINESE REVOLUTIONTheses for Propagand-
  ists
, Approved by the C.C., C.P.S.U.(B.)


657

I.
II.
III.
IV.
 

Prospects of the Chinese Revolution
The First Stage of the Chinese Revolution
The Second Stage of the Chinese Revolution
Errors of the Opposition
 

657
659
662
664
 

TALK WITH STUDENTS OF THE SUN YAT-SEN UNIVERSITYMay 13,
  1927
 


667
 

THE REVOLUTION IN CHINA AND THE TASKS OF THE COMINTERN.
  Speech Delivered at the Tenth Sitting, Eighth Plenum of the
  E.C.C.I.
, May 241927


 
696

I.
II.
 
III.
 
 
IV.
V.
 

Some Minor Questions
The Agrarian-Peasant Revolution as the Basis of the Bour-
geois-Democratic Revolution
The Right Kuomintang in Nanking, Which Massacres Commun-
ists, and the Left Kuomintang in Wuhan, Which Maintains an
Alliance with the Communists
Soviets of Workers' and Peasants' Deputies in China
Two Lines
 

696
 
699
 
 
707
710
720
 

NOTES ON CONTEMPORARY THEMES

726

I.
II.
 

The Threat of War
China
 

726
734
 

JOINT PLENUM OF THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE AND THE CENTRAL
  CONTROL COMMISSION OF THE C.P.S.U.(B.), July 29-August 9,
  1927


 
765

  The International Situation and the Defense of the U.S.S.R.
    Speech Delivered on August 1


765

I.
II.
III.
IV.

The Attacks of the Opposition on Sections of the Comintern
About China
The Anglo-Soviet Unity Committee
The Threat of War and the Defence of the U.S.S.R.

765
772
797
802

  Speech Delivered on August 5
  With Reference to the Opposition's "Declaration" of August 8,
    1927. Speech Delivered on August 9
 

819
 
843
 

THE POLITICAL COMPLEXION OF THE RUSSIAN OPPOSITION.
  Excerpts from a Speech Delivered at a Joint Meeting of the
  Presidium of the Executive Committee of the Comintern and
  the International Control Commission
, September 27, 1927
 


 
 
850
 

THE TROTSKYIST OPPOSITION BEFORE AND NOWSpeech Delivered
  at a Meeting of the Joint Plenum of the Central Committee and
  the Central Control Commission of the C.P.S.U.(B.)
, October 23,
  1927


 
 
864

I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
VII.
 
VIII.
 

Some Minor Questions
The Opposition's "Platform"
Lenin on Discussions and Oppositions in General
The Opposition and the "Third Force"
How the Opposition Is "Preparing" for the Congress
From Leninism to Trotskyism
Some of the Most Important Results of the Party's Policy
During the Past Few Years
Back to Axelrod
 

864
869
874
875
880
884
 
887
892
 

NOTES

943



From Marx
to Mao

Stalin
Collection

Reading
Guide

Problems
of Leninism